top of page

Culturalism

Writer: Jan Dehn
Jan Dehn
Oct 4
6 min read

Updated: Oct 20

Victims and perpetrators of culturalism (Source: here) 


Culturalism is the cultural equivalent of racism. Where racism prioritises one race over other races, culturalism places some people over others based on their cultural affiliations. Culturalism arises whenever members of a more powerful culture impose their values and customs on members of less powerful cultures.

 

In many countries, prescriptive culturalist practices are institutionalised through policies, laws, and regulations, which explicitly favour certain cultural practices, while discriminating against others. An obvious, if banal, example is the practice in most European countries of assigning the status of 'state religion' to one or other branch of Christianity, but not to non-Christian religions.

 

Culturalism is at least as widespread globally as racism was in the US South prior to de-segregation. It lies at the root of some of worst political excesses anywhere in the world, including identity politics, discrimination, xenophobia, degrading treatment and deportation of refugees to third countries, nonchalant acceptance that thousands of Africans drown in the Mediterranean Sea trying to cross into Europe every year, genocides, such as Gaza, and war.

 

When podcaster Konstantin Kisin said former British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak could never be English, because he is a "brown Hindu", Kisin was expressing a culturalist view. We also see culturalism in the Indian caste system and in Prime Minister Modi's overt sponsorship of Hinduism. We see it in the efforts of religious fundamentalists in the United States to ban abortion. We see it expressed in tribal tensions between Hutus and Tutsis in Rwanda and between Luos and Kikuyus in Kenya. We see it in the subordination of women in business and politics in almost every country in the world. We see it very prominently expressed in Zionism, which claims that members of the Jewish culture have a unique and exclusive right to land in and around present-day Israel, solely based on their membership of the Jewish culture (see here).

 

Yet, it only takes a moment of contemplation to recognise that culture-based claims to privilege are arbitrary and non-sensical. Culture, like religion, is basically a postcode lottery. Where we are born determines which culture we get. I have Danish cultural values, because I happen to have been born and grown up in Denmark. Had I been born in Turkey, my values would have been completely different, but they would still have felt natural to me. In other words, culture is a social construct and nothing intrinsically links us to our culture other than where we were born and bred.


There are literally hundreds of cultures in the world, each one with its own unique customs and underlying value system. All are internally consistent, which is why they have lasted for so long. None can claim to be better than any other. They are just different social constructs.


We all grew up inside one of these social constructs and most of us got so brainwashed along the way that we believe our own cultural values are somehow universal. But this is not true. No culture can claim universality. The only reason we think this way is that most of us have only lived within one culture and know little else.

 

It is precisely this asymmetry, which gives rise to the many problems associated with culturalism. We all have intimate knowledge of and close familiarity with our own culture, but most of us are woefully ignorant of other cultures.


Unfortunately, our ignorance of other cultures is also tinged with suspicion, because our cultural identities were originally forged as a way to defend vulnerable communities against external threats. In the distant past, long before we had rule of law, small groups of human societies formed strong intra-communal ties that were based on shared cultural values, because it helped them to unite when they faced enemies. This is how we have come to associate shared cultural values with trust and alien cultures with danger.

 

It is therefore no wonder that humans so easily resort to discrimination along cultural lines; it is literally how we survived for tens of thousands of years. Yet, this basic method of defence, which served us so well before the rule of law, is now obsolete; with laws in place and police and military to enforce them we no longer have to rely on cultural affinity to be safe. In fact, as I will argue below, doing so may actually hold us back.

 

Unfortunately, we still harbour instincts of cultural defensiveness, which are easily activated and exploited by populist politicians. This results in many policies, which blatantly discriminate along cultural lines. Moreover, most people don't even recognise culture-based discrimination as anything other than natural and reasonable. The typical mindset of many is that 'we' have a right to decide how people coming to our countries must live, because it is 'our' country and our culture was here first!


It is precisely this near-universal obliviousness to its problems that makes culturalism the most widespread and least recognised of all the major types of discrimination in the world today. Every single hour of every day countless political opportunists the world over work very hard to force cultural minorities to adopt the customs and rules of dominant cultures against their will.


We see culturalist coercion expressed in the bans on burqas imposed on Muslim women in at least 24 countries as well as in the proscription of burqas for Muslim women in Afghanistan. We see it expressed in demands from nativists in rich countries that immigrants go home, because 'their kind' have no right to live in 'our' countries.


Every day, culturalist politicians vilify perfectly ordinary, law-abiding immigrant families, who have come to the West with the sole aims of working and improving their lives; they are habitually portrayed as welfare scoungers, job-stealers, extremists.

 

This type of scapegoating of cultural minorities is, of course, as old as the hills. It has featured in every pogrom, every genocide, every Apartheid system, every class system, every caste system. Surely, we all know where it leads?


Well, it seems not. It never fails to shock me how many of us are completely OK with culture-based coercion within our own societies. The explanation, it seems to me, is that deep down many of us believe that being part of a majority culture gives us the right to dictate how minorities live.

 

It is this attitude, which makes culturalism so dark. While culture brings us many delights, it is also a vicious tool for social control. Culture, when used to discriminate against others, can be as awful as racism, sexism, homophobia, and other types of discrimination based on people's features and preferences.

 

Due to these dangers, it is my strongly held view that culture should never be a policy issue. Culture should be left as a choice for each of us to make, an individual's take it or leave it proposition. Culture must be free in order to have meaning and be able to evolve. Culture must never be prescribed.


In my view, there is not a single valid reason why Western societies would need to prescribe culture; as long as people obey the country's laws they should be free to live as they please.

 

We are very far from that point today. It is taboo in many societies even to mention that dominant cultures do not have the right to dictate how cultural minorities should live. To move forward, we need an open debate about culturalism. We need to recognise that our politicians ruthlessly exploit our asymmetric cultural understanding. We need to face the fact that we impose cultural tyranny on minorities and that there are real victims. We need to confront the reality that we sweep many of our own cultural injustices under the carpet.

 

My primary concern is for the victims of cultural coercion, but I recognise that moral arguments will not sway everyone. To those who only care about themselves, I say this: it is also in your narrow self-interest to get along better with people from other cultures. Remember that Western populations are shrinking due to falling birth rates and ageing populations, so we need more immigrants to maintain current living standards. Besides, the world continues to get smaller due to improvements in transport, communication, and income per capita, which are all unstoppable. More and more of us will therefore come into contact with one another. Do we really want these ever-more frequent cross-cultural encounters to turn into clashes, or should we put them to better use?

 

Given the inexorability of globalisation, tomorrow's winners will those who thrive in multi-cultural communities, while the losers will be found among those who can't adapt to an ever-shrinking world. To make sure as many of us as possible end up on the winning side, we need to actively take on culturalism, that is, work to overcome our cultural information asymmetries. Above all, this will require investment in cultural awareness. As an economist, I never thought I would say this, but the truth is that the future for social anthropology looks great! We will really need their skills as we try to come to terms with the world of tomorrow.


The End

 

Comments


©2026 by Jan Dehn

bottom of page