The (Brexit) tide turns


The Brexit tide finally starts to turn (Source: here)
Since 2008/09, a battle has been raging in Western democracies between the forces of progress and proponents of what I call culturalism, the cultural equivalent of racism.
Culturalists are deeply uncomfortable with an ever-integrating world. They have been trying for the better part of two decades to take the world back to a mythical past before brown people arrived, before Eastern Europeans arrived, before China became a world power, before BRICS, before the manufacturing jobs went to Asia.
For nearly two decades, in the name of reverting to some imaginary 'good times', culturalists have destroyed free trade, turned on society's most vulnerable, undermined the welfare state, overseen the greatest rise in income inequality in modern times, rolled back human rights, turned state media organisations into instruments of Far-Right propaganda, broken highly effective defence alliances, such as NATO, gutted the United Nations, cut foreign aid, turned their backs on science and vaccines, and attacked courts, whose only jobs it has been to protect basic human rights and the rule of law.
The whole world has paid a great price for these follies and perhaps no one paid a higher price than the good people of Great Britain, who, in 2016, took delusional romanticisation of the past to unprecedented extremes by leaving the European Union. I think it speaks volumes about the true toll of culturalism in extremis that Britain, the country that went further than any other down the path of culturalism, is now among the first to turn tail.
Over the past decade, the British people have suffered the unmitigated consequences of economic nationalism in the guise of Brexit. They are now turning their backs on culturalism precisely because they have lived it. I, for one, am delighted that they have finally reached this level of insight.
Yesterday's deal between British Prime Minister Andy Burnham and the European Union begins to reverse the damage. It eases Brexit controls on trade in food and drink, including agricultural goods. Emission trading schemes also get reconnected, so that both sides can avoid levies, while young Europeans get to live and work in the UK - and vice versa. Trade in goods and services improves and red tape declines - a double win for both sides.
It is almost unfathomable how anyone - especially economic experts - could ever have imagined it to be any other way.
Still, there is a long way to go. Beginnings look like this, with modest progress at first, then faster growth, and, finally, the flood. The reason why things will speed up from here is simple: progress lies in the future, not in the past. Brexiters wanted to take Britain back into the past, but Britain was never going to reach the future by shrinking into an inferior former version of itself. You sometimes need to grow to reach the future. Nothing is better for growth than making a few mistakes along the way.
The ramifications of Britain's Brexit saga extend beyond British shores. Economic nationalism in the United States and in several other Western nations will suffer the same fate as Brexit. Why? Because globalisation, the driving force behind all progress, is inevitable. The fuel of globalisation is technical progress, better transportation, better communications, higher GDP per capita. These are forces, which are so powerful that no one, not even the most ardent culturalists, can stop them.
The big truth we in the West must now face is that we either adapt to globalisation or see our economies and therefore, eventually, also our cultures die, which is exactly what was happening to Britain under Brexit.
Far too many people are still not mature enough, or educated enough, or simply not intelligent enough to understand this. It is the responsibility of our political leaders to convince them that their fears of other cultures are misplaced; the cultural diversity they fear so much no longer poses any threat whatsoever as long as we have human rights, rule of law, and democracy.
This means that no one is going to stop the Brits from eating toad-in-the-hole, pickled eggs, or mushy peas. No one is going to stop Danes from eating stegt flæsk. In fact, if we are lucky, we have some Syrian immigrant or a chap from China run our beloved greasy spoon, because our own cultural 'brothers' sure as hell won't do it.
We need to adapt aggressively to globalisation. The first step has to be to sow broader acceptance of the inevitability of globalisation in Western populations. Once this rather daunting objective has been achieved, we must put policies in place that are appropriate for a globalising world. For individual nation states, the means integrating far deeper into larger regional trade and governance bodies, such as the European Union. In fact, our beloved nation states must eventually cease to exist altogether.
That last sentence will be a bit of a mouthful to many, but the logic is irrefutable. The four biggest problems of our time are already completely beyond the policy reach of individual nation states. I call them the Four Horsemen - terrorism, financial contagion, immigration and climate change. They can only be solved at regional level, which is why nation states must surrender sovereignty to larger democratic bodies, which can then put genuinely effective region-wide defences in place. Britain just learnt that very lesson from its Brexit misadventure; it is better to be part of a greater whole.
Beyond accepting the inevitability of globalisation and the desirability of surrendering sovereignty to larger regional economic and political bodies, the big personal challenge each of us faces is to defeat the culturalist monster within us. Since the earliest human cohabitation, our communities have relied on culture-based mechanisms for defence. We have developed powerful cultural practices to encourage cohesion within our group and mistrust of outsiders as ways to recognise external threats and keep our communities safe. Unfortunately, these defensive cultural instincts are now obsolete, counter-productive even, made redundant by rule of law, human rights, and democracy.
To make this point completely clear, let me draw an analogy between culturalism and obesity. For almost all of human history, we lived on the edge of starvation, which is why we developed powerful urges to eat whenever we see food. However, in today's Western world with its abundance of cheap food the urge to eat with abandon whenever we see food makes us obese, kills us even with lifestyle diseases, such as diabetes, heart disease, and cancers.
Wouldn't it be lovely if we could just pop a version of Ozempic or Wegowy to cure us of culturalism? Pending the arrival of such drugs, unless and until we educate our populations to better cope with cultural diversity we will find ourselves at the mercy of a great Darwinian filtering mechanism, which will strongly favour those who are comfortable living and working with people from other cultures, while ruthlessly culling the rest.
Your task, dear reader, is to decide which group you want to belong to.
The End




Comments